Monday 22nd May 2017
Theresa May's Manifesto Pledge... Will Mean the Greatest NHS Property Sell-Off Ever!
On Monday 22nd May, in a
BBC interview with Andrew Neil,
Theresa May was asked about the Conservative manifesto pledge on health that it claims would implement
the most ambitious programme of investment in buildings and technology that the NHS has ever seen. In her answer Theresa May claimed that there would be an extra £10bn of capital funding for the NHS over the next Parliament if the Conservatives won the general election. She claimed that building and technology funding was
separate from the NHS revenue funding and said that the capital funding would come from a
variety of sources but refused to give further details other than to say that "we are backing the proposals in the Naylor Report".
What does the Naylor Report say? Sir Robert Naylor's
independent report was commissioned by the Secretary for State for Health (Jeremy Hunt), and was published in March 2017. The report sets out a new direction of strategy for NHS estates in England. Yet while the report claims to be dealing in part with the backlog of repair (estimated at £5bn) to existing NHS estates, he claims that such a backlog can no longer be fully funded when he says:
“This review was predicated on widely accepted assumptions that the NHS estate is not currently configured to maximise benefits for patients or taxpayers.” p.3.
His report starts by saying:
“My review set out to develop a new NHS estate strategy, which supports the delivery of specific Department of Health (DH) targets to release £2bn of assets for reinvestment and to deliver land for 26,000 new homes ...This work suggests that the NHS can release £2bn of assets and deliver 26,000 homes and with an effective programme of interventions in high value propositions in London, this could significantly increase the property receipts to a figure exceeding £5bn in the longer term.” p.2.
In other words, a new Conservative government together with NHS England will attempt to hide massive cuts to existing infrastructure in 'investment in buildings and technology', by selling off NHS land and buildings for housing plots to go to the big housing corporations. In line with this direction the Naylor Report also recommends the "acceleration" of Sustainability and Transformation Plans (STPs), which mean the closures of District Hospitals and other locally based NHS services through "incentives" p.2. The report says:
“At a minimum, the Department of Health (DH) and HM Treasury (HMT) should provide robust assurances to STPs that any sale receipts from locally owned assets will not be recovered centrally provided the disposal is in agreement with STP plans. This report recommends that HMT should provide additional funding to incentivise land disposals through a '2 for 1 offer' in which public funds match disposal receipts.” p.5.
To enact this great land and building sell off the Naylor Report also recommends the establishment of a powerful new arms-length NHS Property Board:
“which provides leadership to the centre and expertise and delivery support to Sustainability and Transformation Plans (STPs). It should be a strategic organisation, at arms-length from the Department of Health and structured so that it empowers speedy executive action and professional credibility within the sector. To include a regional structure, which is aligned with NHS England (NHSE) & NHS Improvement (NHSI) and brings together functions of NHS Property Services (NHS PS), Community Health Partnerships (CHP) and other fragmented NHS property capabilities into a single organisation.” p.33.
NHS Property Services (NHS PS), formerly 'NHS Propco', was set up in 2012 following the Health and Social Care Act, having taken over £5bn worth of property - some 3,500 properties - including offices, primary care, and community health facilities formerly used by the Primary Care Trusts. On this the Naylor Report says a shadow form of the NHS Property Board should be set up immediately and it should
consider if the functions and residual assets it inherits from the abolition of Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) should be divested back to providers. Otherwise all this property will become part of this great sell-off of NHS property being implemented by a future Conservative government, or part of it as Trusts are forced to dispose of NHS property and land through the STPs or to cover their
In reporting on the comment of Theresa May that this funding would come from a "variety of sources", the Health Service Journal said: "HSJ understands that although some will be new money from the Treasury, much will come from private sources and sales of existing NHS estate". On this the Naylor Report says:
“Substantial capital investment is needed to deliver service transformation in well evidenced STP plans. We envisage that the total capital required by these plans is likely to be around £10bn, in the medium term, which could be met by contributions from three sources; property disposals, private capital (for primary care) and from HMT.” p.38.
It is no wonder that Theresa May was reluctant to mention more details when she said that "investment in buildings and technology" would be funded by a "variety of sources" because this includes the greatest NHS property sell off ever seen and the increasing use of private capital and privatisation of community health services as implicit in the Naylor Report. In this respect the creation of the Accountable Care Organisations (ACOs) - modelled on the US style private health care system - are already being talked about as one of the models for the STPs which the next government will use.
In the present battle to safeguard the future of the NHS and to build an alternative future, what is being further revealed by Theresa May's plan for NHS infrastructure is the neoliberalisation of health care and the aim of destroying the social ownership of the NHS and the destruction of public assets and public authority by a central government that represents the neoliberal interests of health and other monopolies. This contemporary development is a systematic attempt to wreck the public health care system by centralising the destruction of public authority over the NHS, and to hive-off its assets to the rich. It is why the people should continue to fight to establish themselves as the new public authority that upholds the right of all to health care and demand social ownership of the NHS by building the independent political movement of the working class and people to safeguard the future of the NHS.
Theresa May fully supports the Naylor Report
Vlogger Chris Holden tells you everything you need to know about the Naylor Report!
Monday 7th June 2017
The current government has told NHS England to 'think the unthinkable' on cuts and closures but keep it secret until after the General Election.
It has been revealed by the Health Service Journal (HSJ) that NHS
England are planning
unthinkable measures including closing
services, stopping treatments and systematically extending waiting
times, because of the deficit that they have created by the annual
improvement programmes which have not only already led to cuts in
services but have left most hospitals seriously underfunded.
Instead of addressing the funding crisis that they have created in the
NHS, the government and NHS England have instructed fourteen areas of the
country to draw up plans to reduce overspending, including closures of
maternity and Accident & Emergency departments. As we know this is
already being planned in South Tyneside and Sunderland to be revealed
after the election. However South Tyneside is not at this moment one of
the 14 areas that HSJ says are under particular pressure to make
swinging cuts because they are on course to miss agreed
limits. These areas include:
Bristol, South Gloucestershire and North Somerset; Cambridgeshire and Peterborough; Cheshire (Eastern, Vale Royal and South); Cornwall; Devon; Morecambe Bay; Northumbria; North Central London; North Lincolnshire; North West London; South East London; Staffordshire; Surrey and Sussex; Vale of York and Scarborough and Ryedale.
NHS England have said areas were planning how best to spend their money,
and said decisions would require
Remember, Northumbria was supposed to be NHS Health Improvement's flagship area with its pilot of the new STP type services, and has already lost all its A&Es with acute services now concentrated at Cramlington. This means people have to travel huge distances across Northumbria to access emergency services putting people in very great risk all the way from Hexham to Berwick. According to this revelation they are to suffer more cuts to services!
Senior managers told HSJ that they have been instructed to
think the unthinkable.
The measures are currently being discussed in secret by NHS England and NHS Improvement officials, and
will only be revealed after the general election.
According to HSJ the plans being discussed include closing wards and surgical theatres, cutting back on staff, and systematically lengthening waiting times for operations.
Whilst people have already lost the right to free dentistry treatments,
the huge loss of social care, and mental health care for the
elderly, they are also planning the further rationing of what they
low value treatments. Discussions include extending
limits on IVF, which is already subject to a postcode lottery of
Whilst the NHS is suffering an acute shortage of doctors, nurses and hospital beds, the report says they are to cut more staff and beds. The present situation is already that Trusts have been outsourcing operations to the private sector as they cannot manage the capacity. But HSJ says that they will now be discussing limiting the number of free operations provided by private sector providers to reduce their deficits. Ironically, this is all being set up for the new Conservative government to expand the private sector and introduce private health insurance by getting people to fund their own care for planned operations.
This must not pass! What is being further revealed here is Theresa May's plan of neo-liberalisation of health care and a systematic attempt to wreck the public health care system by centralising the destruction of public authority over the NHS and hive off its assets to the rich and make people pay for their health care.
Lets build our movement to safeguard the future of the NHS.
...Let June 8th be the end of May
- Public Meetings
- Press Releases / Briefings / Open Letters
- Marches and Demonstrations
- Lectures / Presentations
- Articles from 2019
- Articles from 2018
- Articles from 2017
- Articles from 2016
- Our Comments and Questions on the Working Ideas for Phase-2
- Where We Are & Going Into 2019
- Submissions to South Tyneside CCG Listening Panel
- Response to National Survey on ICP Contracting
- Response to Announced Merger Between STFT and CHS
- Fundraisers and Celebrations | Summer-2018
- National March and Rally for #ourNHS70
- Taking Our Fight to Westminster
- North East March and Rally for the NHS | 2018
- Pending Decision on 'Path to Excellence' Consultation Phase-1
- Protests Against Maternity and SCBU Closure
- South Tyneside March and Rally | 2017
- Mini-March to Save Children's A&E
- Public Meeting at Hedworthfield Community Centre | September-2017
- Joint Health Scrutiny Committee
- Public Meeting at Brinkburn Community Centre | July-2017
- Response to Consultation Phase-1
- NHS Post Election Reflections
- South Tyneside May Day Rally and Celebration | 2017
- National March and Rally for #ourNHS
- North East March and Rally for the NHS | 2017
- KONP Campaign Workshop
- Response to STP
- Call to Publish STP
- SSTHC Supports Footprints March
- First March to Defend Our Hospital and NHS
- Jarrow March 80th Anniversary
- First Public Meeting